Thursday, March 23, 2023

Riley Williams Sentenced to Three Years

Girls Just Wanna Have Fun!

Riley June Williams, Felon


It turns out that trying to overthrow the government on a lark may be a bad idea. I've been checking in with Riley Williams for quite a while. She may or may not have stolen Nancy Pelosi's laptop (that charge was eventually dropped), but she definitely had fun in the nation's Capitol on January 6, 2021. 

I was worried early on that the Feds would tire of the workload generated by January 6 and, after a certain amount of time had passed, start to let the small-fry cases slide. Riley was my test case, and I was wrong. She was definitely never at the head of the line - other, more important, cases clearly came first - but she never fell out of the line. 

Riley was arrested on January 18, 2021, but allowed to remain at her mother's home in central Pennsylvania while her case was pending. And it pended for quite a while. I do think the prosecutors were interested in getting Speaker Pelosi's laptop back, but Riley clearly was not willing to play ball. 

She also didn't like the conditions of her home detention and quietly violated them on several occasions, presumably thinking her transgressions would not be detected. 

In America you're innocent until convicted, so at this point Riley was innocent. But, golly, she seemed blissfully unaware of how nice the authorities were being to her. The judge even allowed her to go to the Pennsylvania Renaissance Faire. The prosecutors argued from the beginning that she was a flight risk,  and I think they would have been happier with Riley in jail.

At any rate she was finally indicted on October 6, 2021. And then the case dragged on again, eventually going to trial on November 7, 2022, in Washington, D.C. A jury found her guilty on November 21, and the judge ordered her to go to jail and await sentencing. Riley, who was 23 years old at this point, appeared shocked that she was going to jail.

On March 23, she was sentenced to 36 months in jail.

Riley strikes me as a somewhat aimless, slightly bored young person who wanted to have some excitement in her life. Nothing criminal about that, but then she seems to have fallen in with some bad company. Politico reported that she was a Groyper, which seems to mean she was a fan of Nick Fuentes, a rather appalling young man. You may recall that, late last year, he brought Kanye West to dinner with Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago. 

Riley's lawyer, a hard-working Federal Defender named Lori Ulrich, did what she could, and two of the most serious charges against Riley wound up being dropped. But the evidence on the remaining charges was overwhelming, and the verdict was fair.

Jail changes people. I'd like to think that Riley will come out of the penitentiary a better person, but frankly I doubt this will happen. I don't ever expect to hear her start a sentence with, "I made some bad decisions." Instead I think she'll come out hardened and bitter. And that's a pity.

See also What a Cold Civil War Feels Like, A Shortage of Serviceable Ducks, Slingshot, A Home Invasion, As the Tide Goes Out.

Saturday, March 4, 2023

Lighting Rittenhouse

Too White, Too Bright in the Square

Addison Street from 18th.


I'm starting this story on Addison Street because my underlying purpose here is to expand people's horizons when it comes to how we light the outdoors. Don't worry. I'll be getting to Rittenhouse Square very soon.

Addison Street is approximately two blocks from Rittenhouse Square. Quite a while ago now, the residents decided to wrap their trees with Christmas lights.  Currently the lights are on, as far as I can tell, around the clock and every day of the year. The bulbs are LEDs.

There are actually two regular street lights on this block. They're standard highway lights, very tall, with goose necks. These lights work well on highways, particularly Interstates, where they provide even illumination across large areas that are not obstructed by objects like trees, and where motorists can be relied on to be staring at the highway in front of them, and not trying to look up at the night sky.

On Addison, the two highway lights are almost invisible. If you look carefully at the picture above you can see one of them, hiding up among the trees in the background. There's a patch of pavement directly under that light that's a bit brighter than the surrounding street. 

The trees are basically eating the light from these two highway lamps, and much of the illumination on this block comes from the lights on the trees and the porch lights on the houses. 

 Mixing Light, Balancing Light

Let's have a look at how the tree lights work during the day - remember, they're on just about all the time.


I love the way the afternoon sunlight in this picture, painting the facades of the houses, receives a delicate complement from the bulbs wrapping the tree.

Mixing light from multiple sources goes on all the time. I don't think people necessarily think a lot about mixing sunlight with artificial lights, but frankly it also goes on all the time, and this is a particularly pleasant example. 

When mixing lights it's important to see that they're balanced. Balancing doesn't mean every light needs to be the same. It means the lights need to work together and not fight one another.

Afternoon on the Square


Let's have a look at how sunlight works on Rittenhouse Square. Mother Nature, and her buddy the sun, have been teaching humans about light for a very long time. And I think it's fair to say that the impulse behind artificial illumination is to extend some form of daylight into the hours and places of darkness.

I think Mother Nature does a particularly good job of lighting Rittenhouse Square during the day. In summer the dappled light, created by a collaboration of the sun and trees, creates a very pleasant effect.


The only lighting problem during the day lies on the south side of the square, which is largely covered in shadows cast by the tall buildings on that side. The area still gets quite a lot of use, just not very much from sunbathers.

As Day Turns to Night 

My favorite part of the day is the time around sunset, when the sun shows what a talented lighting designer it really is.

First, late in the afternoon, comes the golden hour, when the low sun floods planet earth with gorgeous, powerful, golden light. In this context, "hour" is a flexible term. And the golden hour doesn't happen every day - the weather needs to cooperate. But that just makes it all the more precious.

Sunsets can bring their own joys of course, but they tend to be hard to see from the square, so I'm not going to talk about them here.

Starting as the sun sets we have the blue hour. With the departure of the sun's rays, the surface of the earth needs to look to the sky for light, and that light is blue. (The sun is still shining up there.) So the earth becomes blue, and the people walking around are blue, although we know they're not really blue. 

At its best, the blue hour is a soft, subtle time before the sky goes a velvety black. Many of the pictures in this story were taken during the blue hour. I find they're just nicer pictures. Here's a shot of a building entrance on the south side of the square. 


I love the warm, even illumination of the canopy lights, and I'm very fond of the blue masonry in the facade above the canopy. Again, it's not really blue, it just looks that way. At night, when the light of the sun has completely left the sky, the upper part of the facade will be black, perhaps punctuated by a few lit windows. 

I can work with the blackness of night. Here's a shot of the holiday decorations at Longwood Gardens.


Note that, in this picture, virtually all of the background details have dropped out. You can just barely make out a few figures walking on the path by the trees. They're being lit by the lights on the trees.

Talk about abstract art. The trees have been abstracted from their environment.

To Balance or Not to Balance

Also on the south side of the square is this building. Years ago I photographed Ted Kennedy coming out of a fundraiser here. There are a lot of different lights in this picture, but they are all balanced - it's almost balletic - and the overall result is, to my eye at least, very pleasing.


Across the square on the north side, we have this. Note the very bright lights on each side of the doors. They're trying too hard, and the result is an unbalanced lighting scheme.

Attack of the killer photons.


Let's now go across Walnut street and into the park. Recently the park's complement of street lamps got some new bulbs. They are the reason I'm writing this story.

Have a look at this picture of the center of the square. Those are very bright streetlights.

Help! I'm melting ... I'm melting.


Then look at the snowflakes in the trees. The snowflakes and the lamps are fighting one another, and the snowflakes are losing.

As I said earlier, these new lights are too white and too bright. I had been struggling to articulate exactly why I had such a visceral dislike for them, and then I read Vasily Grossman's Life and Fate (English translation 1985). It's a sprawling novel centered on the Battle of Stalingrad during World War II. Here's part of a description of the morning routine at a Soviet labor camp:

"The prisoners were woken by the orderlies at five in the morning. It was still pitch dark; the barrack-huts were lit by the merciless light that is common to prisons, railway stations and the waiting-rooms of city hospitals." (P. 174.)

Merciless light. I like that.

I don't think I'm alone in my concerns about this new, intense illumination. One evening recently, I was leaving the park, a short time after the lights came on, and I passed two women who were entering the park. One turned to the other and said, "Who wrote this lighting plan?"

Here is my surmise: Highway engineers wrote this lighting plan, and they did what they were trained to do.

All the Park's a Stage - or Many Stages

I hope we can all agree that this park is not a highway. I would like to go one step further. I suggest we look at it as a kind of theater - an open-air theatrical venue with a circulating audience and many stages of various sizes. This was clearly the intent of Paul P. Cret, the architect who, before World War I, produced the basic design we see today.

I frankly know very little about lighting design for the stage, so I went to the Free Library and checked out a book - J. Michael Gillette's Theatrical Design and Production (1987). Here's what he has to say about the purpose of theatrical lighting: 

"Obviously, there is something more to stage lighting than simply bathing the stage with light. Effective stage lighting not only lets the spectators see the action of the play but also ties together all the visual elements of the production and helps create an appropriate mood and atmosphere that heighten the audience's understanding and enjoyment of the play." (P. 263.) 

And here are four basic tasks for theatrical lighting, which I have adapted from pages 264-265 of Professor Gillette's book.

Illuminate the stage. The audience needs to see the action on the stage.

Highlights. The most important elements, such as the prima ballerina or the prima donna, should receive extra light. And God help you if you don't have a spotlight on the diva's face at all times.

Modeling. Figures need to appear three dimensional, and faces shouldn't look scary unless it's Halloween.

Mood. Lighting, and particularly color, are powerful generators of mood.

So how are we doing in the square? Let's have a look. Here's a view to the southwest down the main walkway, with a person striding purposefully in our direction.


Even though we're still in the blue hour (note the sky in the background), the wooden benches on the right are highlights threatening to blow out, and the shrubbery on the left is a murky, almost featureless blob. The walkway and the person in the middle of it are bathed in contrasty light that feels chillingly cold.

What young couple would want to pause for a romantic kiss in light like this?

Highlight the Sculpture

Let's have a look at how we're treating the stars of the show out here. They would be the park's sculptures, of which I'm counting five. There's the Duck Girl in the reflecting pool - I think of her as our prima ballerina. And then there are M. Barye's Lion, Billy the Goat, the Giant Frog, and the Sundial. (I'm leaving out a few smaller pieces. For more, click here.) 

These five sculptures all work beautifully in the sunlight. I feel badly for them after sunset. They all basically disappear. Have a look at the Duck Girl. She's a dark blob out in the reflecting pool, and you certainly can't see her face.


I did notice a little something in the drained reflecting pool, directly in front of the Duck Girl. I think this may be a light, but I'm not sure because I don't recall ever seeing it lit.


You may have noticed, in the wide shot of the fountain and the reflecting pool above, that the right side of the fountain wall is brighter than the left side. A few days later I had a closer look and discovered this.


The reason for the light differential is that the easternmost of the three bulbs jury-rigged in here is not functioning. (A few days after I took this shot, I went back, and the bulbs had been removed.)

The only sculpture that is currently lit is Barye's Lion.  I'll be gentle and say the lighting here has been inadequate for a long time, and the situation has only gotten worse with the arrival of the new bulbs in the street lamps. 

The other three sculptures are the goat, the frog, and the sundial. They all lack dedicated illumination.

The Guardhouse

I would be remiss if I didn't mention the guardhouse in the center of the square. It is a lovely structure, beautifully lit, and I think it bears up reasonably well under the new lights. But it looks better when the streetlights are turned off.


Rescue the Blue Hour

So, beyond the sculpture, how do we fix the overall lighting scheme in Rittenhouse Square? Let's start our planning with the blue hour.

I think a lot of city dwellers are blissfully unaware that the blue hour exists. That's partly because we hardly ever get its full effect in the city - the artificial lights are too bright. Instead of trying to drown the blue hour in photons, I suggest we celebrate it. 

Time is a dimension. The gates of night lie in the blue, but we don't need to rush through them. Let's see how the lights can help us with that. Right now, they don't actually all come on at once. They seem to go on by segments - a line here, a group there. But they all go on within about ten minutes of sundown.

Let's organize this process around something other than the demands of electrical circuitry, increasing the light gradually as the need for illumination increases. We might even want to put all these lights on dimmer switches, so a lamp could start softly and gradually get brighter. 

That way we'd be able to see more of the blue hour, instead of essentially shutting it down shortly after it starts.

Soften the Night

Leaves eat light. Grass eats light. It's what Mother Nature designed them to do. If you want to replicate daylight in the nighttime park, you need to cut down the trees and pave the lawns. Then you will have a facsimile of a parking lot in a suburban shopping mall. I suggest we instead aim to get our nightlights to work with the park instead of fighting it.

The point here is to put the light where it's needed to achieve your goals - which I think should be illumination, highlights, modeling, and mood. Instead of wasting electricity to feed trees from lamps on high poles, put the lights where they're needed, which is generally close to the ground.

You want people to see the pathways they're walking on, so they don't trip and fall. Put low lights on short poles - knee-high or waist-high - along the edge of the walk. 

You're worried about women being dragged off into the bushes? Light the bushes. There's no place to hide on Addison street at night. To quote Ernest Hemingway, a clean, well-lighted place. 

And yes, the very bright, merciless light that we're getting more and more of in this town actually makes the shadows look darker to the human eye. 

You want a soft, romantic mood? Kill the NASA-spec lights. They're useful on a launch pad at night, but we don't need them here. 

Will Rittenhouse Square ever look like Longwood Gardens, or even Addison street? I doubt it. But there are many opportunities for improving the light in Rittenhouse Square. It would help to start with a lighting plan that makes sense.

(The Chestnut Hill Local has been doing a good job covering the new streetlights in its area. For three stories and a letter to the editor, click here, here, here, and here.)

See also Paul P. Cret and Rittenhouse Square, Night Lights at Coney Island, City of Lights.

Friday, February 3, 2023

Why Did It Crash?

The Bicycle Boom of the 1890s

Sunday in Central Park. Marjory Collins/FSA, 1942.

There's a cloud that lurks over the current boom in bicycling. It's often invisible, but in stressful times it seeps in like a fog. And for veterans of the last few decades of bicycling in the United States, I don't think it ever really goes away.

The cloud is the meteoric rise and equally precipitous collapse of American bicycling in the 1890s. For most people, this history seems about as relevant as Homer's recounting of the fall of Troy.

And I think that's accurate. The fall of Troy, the fall of the Roman Empire, the Dutch Tulip Bubble, all this history lives today even for people who are unaware of it. And the collapse of bicycling in America, on a smaller scale, informs the views of bicycle advocates today, and I think it informs the views of the anti-bicycle group, many of whom are completely unaware of the history.

So will our present bike boom also crash? I don't think so. I think it's a durable boom. I think the only question is how big bicycling will become in places like Philadelphia.

Durability

But let's start with durability. Here's a story. On January 17 of this year, I had occasion to visit the medical city on the west side of the South Street bridge; as I was leaving, I decided to count the number of bicycles parked in the bike racks that are, at this point, basically everywhere on Civic Center Boulevard and on the surrounding streets. I found 244 bikes and electric scooters (there were about a dozen scooters; I didn't count them separately).

I thought that was a pretty good count, and then, as I walked home, I remembered that I had conducted the same count a few years ago.  

After I got home I searched around a bit on my computer and found the email I had written on August 28, 2015. I had had a doctor's appointment that morning, and I had counted the bikes around 10 a.m., the same time I counted this year. 

In 2015, I counted 335. (I don't recall any electric scooters.)

My first reaction was surprise. I hadn't expected to see a drop in the bike count. But then I said, Okay, knucklehead, have you heard of the coronavirus? 

And then I remembered that in 2015 it was a "beautiful day" in August, as I mentioned in my email, and this year's count was on a cool, overcast day in January. I'm willing to concede a certain amount of seasonality in the amount of bicycle commuting in Philadelphia.

Every year, the Bicycle Coalition of Greater Philadelphia counts the number of bikes crossing the Schuylkill River bridges at rush hour. In 2021, the rate was 639 per hour, down from the peak of 913 in 2017. In 2015, the first time I counted parked bikes, the count was 780 per hour. So the bridge counts and my parking counts seem to be roughly in agreement. 

Looking at my 244 count for this year, and thinking about all these things, I've decided 244 is good evidence that our current bicycle boom is remarkably durable. If this little cavalry squadron, parked around Civic Center Boulevard, could survive the Covid epidemic, I don't think it's going away.

(I've also been made aware that there are now indoor bike racks for about 50 bicycles in the 3600 Civic Center Boulevard garage, which I did not count. For a map of bike parking spots at Penn, click here. I only counted the racks on or very near Civic Center Boulevard.)

How Big?

So how big can biking get in Philly? As I've often said, I think bikes and their assorted fellow travelers could see a 50 percent mode share in center city and surrounding areas. This is essentially the older part of the city, which was originally built for pedestrians and horses and wagons, not cars. This area, with its many small streets, is where the viability of our current over-reliance on automobiles is most obviously in question every day.

The key to a 50 percent mode share for bikes and scooters is a complete, fully connected network of protected bike lanes. 

Here's why. When it comes to bicycling, people fall into four groups: the strong and fearless, the enthused and confident, the interested but concerned, and the no way, no how. The strong and fearless are people like bicycle messengers, and research indicates they comprise perhaps 1 percent of the population. The enthused and confident are those who are willing to share traffic lanes with motor vehicles when necessary. They are about 7 percent of the population. The interested but concerned are generally not biking around town for a simple reason: They fear a crash with a motor vehicle that leaves them with a life-altering injury, or possibly just dead. They are about 60 percent of the population. The no way no how group has several subgroups. Some people, because of illness or injury, are simply unable to ride. Some people actively dislike bicyclists and would never get on a bicycle themselves. And others are simply uninterested. The no way no how group is about one-third of the population. (For an interesting article on the history of this typology, click here.)

So the interested but concerned are 60 percent of the population. Here's how you get them riding. You build a complete, fully connected network of protected bike lanes. Then you'll be appealing to about 70 percent of the population, instead of 7 percent.

If we look at pre-pandemic bicycling data for center city and south Philadelphia, you can see that it's already over 7 percent in a few places. The Center City District reports that, in 2017, commuter cycling mode share was 7.3 percent in center city and 8.1 percent in south Philadelphia. These are the most recent data available from CCD.  In 2020 the Bicycle Coalition found a section of south Philadelphia where the bike commuter mode share was 21 percent. 

Have the interested but concerned started commuting by bike? Perhaps. Or maybe the 21-percent spot has a concentration of the enthused and confident? I think it's a good reminder that this typology is a useful tool, and not a sacred tablet.

Just in case you're thinking that everybody else is driving, pedestrian mode share in center city hovers around 30 percent. Transit, before the pandemic, was 20 percent. Motor vehicles had a mode share under 40 percent. (For more, click here.) This motor-vehicle mode share makes center city Philly look more like a European city than an American one, where the private motor-vehicle mode share is generally in the eighties or nineties. Munich, for instance, has a car mode share of 34 percent. But don't worry, we're still not Amsterdam! It has a private-car mode share of 27 percent. (For mode-share levels in cities around the world, click here.) 

How will things look as we finally get back to something resembling normal? I'm hopeful that we'll be getting data on this soon. But center city is definitely recovering. The Center City District provides monthly pedestrian counts, and in November 2022 it reported that pedestrian traffic had reach three-quarters of its pre-pandemic volume. (To see these reports, click here.)

What Does a Pretty Good Bike-Lane Network Look Like?

The medical city on the west side of the Schuylkill has some of the best bicycle routes in Philadelphia. They're not perfect, but they're pretty good, and they keep getting better. The South street bridge has very good bike lanes. They connect to other bike lanes east of the Schuylkill that carry you almost to the Delaware. Chestnut street now has a bike lane that runs from 45th street in west Philly to 22nd street in center city, where it connects with the 22nd street bike lane. In the near future we will be getting a new two-way cycle track on Market street between 20th and 23rd, also connecting with the 22nd street bike lane. (Construction is basically complete, and we are just awaiting a few final touches.) Penndot will also be rebuilding the Market street bridge soon, and the hope is that the bicycle connections there will improve dramatically, including a connection to the trail on the Schuylkill Banks.

I think you can get a sense of the effect of all this lane construction when you look at the bike racks around the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania and Children's Hospital of Philadelphia. 

Bikes are here to stay. The only real question is this: Will we do biking well, or will we do it badly?
If recent history is any guide, progress will be slow, opposition will be intense and effective, and we will eventually get what we need. 

It Was a Different World

But there's always the fear that a new mayor will come along and decide to rip out all the bike lanes. This would be a popular move among certain segments of the population.

I don't think it will happen, but it could. Far too many people in this town still view bicycles - and scooters and all their cousins - as temporary interlopers. 

And bicyclists and bicycle advocates themselves, I think, harbor similar thoughts deep in their minds. The difference being that their thoughts are fears rather than hopes.

And I think a big part of this formless dread dates from the collapse of an astonishingly large bicycling culture - one which even had its own bicycle highways - in the years around 1900. (For instance, the Coney Island Cycle Path in Brooklyn ran next to the existing Ocean Parkway for 5.5 miles, from Prospect Park to Coney Island. Estimates of daily ridership during the mid-1890s regularly ran from 25,000 to 30,000. See Evan Friss, The Cycling City, Bicycles and Urban America in the 1890s, 2015, pp. 102-104. This path is still there, with less traffic.)

Why is this dark cloud - so very old - also so persistent? Perhaps it is because we still don't know the whole story of why the collapse happened. A number of good books have come out recently that look at the boom and the collapse, and we already know a lot more than we did. (In addition to Evan Friss's Cycling City, I look principally to James Longhurst, Bike Battles, A History of Sharing the American Road, 2015, chapters 1-3 and another book by  Friss:  On Bicycles, A 200-Year History of Cycling in New York City, 2019, chapters 1-2.) 

The bike boom of the 1890s was led by the League of American Wheelmen (bicycles were called wheels back then). This was an elite organization of well-to-do white men, who were only interested in bicycling as a recreational activity for people like them. They were uninterested in forms of cycling other than recreation - commuting to work, for instance - and they had no interest in bicycling by women or people of color. In other words, even though they clearly had a mass base available to them in the 1890s, they refused to connect to it.

The League was powerful, and it did a lot to promote better roads. At the time America's roads were - how should I put this? - just terrible. And the League had members like John Jacob Astor and John D. Rockefeller, and the roads got better.

But the lack of a mass base and the lack of interest in utility bicycling - commuting, to be sure, but also getting around town to run errands - meant that the movement lacked a firm foundation and was dependent on the whims of the super-rich.

The League's membership peaked in 1898 with 103,000 members. By 1900 it had to declined to 76,000, and by 1902 membership was at 8,000.

So where did all these avid bicyclists go? The obvious culprit would be the arrival of cars, but the real explosion of car ownership did not start until 1908, when Ford introduced the Model T.

In the past I have felt that the collapse was not due to the arrival of cars. However, I've been rethinking this. The Census Bureau reports that, in 1900, car companies produced 5,000 vehicles, and that 8,000 motor vehicles were registered in the United States. By 1907, the year before the Model T was introduced, there were 142,061 cars kicking around America's roads. 

I'm particularly interested in the Oldsmobile. Ransom Olds founded his company in 1897 and didn't do much until 1901, when he produced 425 cars. In 1902 production was up to 2,500, and we were off to the races. 

There was a car boom before the Model T. It was, compared to what came later, tiny. But were there enough of these cars to attract a relatively small market of prosperous young men looking to be early adopters of the next new thing? I don't know, but I'm intrigued.

Last year I was working on a story about the history of Asbury Park, a beach town in New Jersey, eventually titled "Layers at the Beach Front." My wife pointed me to a promotional pamphlet produced by the Pennsylvania Railroad in 1905, promoting a meeting of the National Education Association that would be in Asbury Park that summer. It had some interesting things to say about cars.

"No resort section in the world presents so many delights to the driver and automobilist as Monmouth County, in which is situated Asbury Park. Hundreds of miles of hard roads radiate in all directions, covering a country charming in natural beauty, enhanced by the development of money and brains, and filled with historic associations. ... One may procure vehicles of all kinds from the livery stables maintained in Asbury Park, so that driving and auto rides are frequent."

So cars were clearly an attraction in 1905, and it doesn't feel like they were a novelty. (To see the whole pamphlet, click here.)

I do have a concern about the idea that elite Wheelmen swapped out their bikes for cars. Let's call it the exercise factor. These were people who were accustomed to a certain level of physical activity. Where did they go to burn those calories?

Golf, maybe? Moderate exercise, a bit of competition, and of course the nineteenth hole for refreshments.

Again, I don't know. But it would be interesting to put the membership lists of the League and more local bicycling clubs up against the membership lists of golf clubs in a particular area - say, Philadelphia.

I never thought I'd be writing about bicycles and golf in the same sentence. but here goes: How many ex-Wheelmen joined golf clubs?

Resistance to Change

Today, many of the issues that contributed to the collapse of bicycling around 1900 simply do not apply. Most importantly, cycling today is a mass - and very open and inclusive - movement. But there were other issues - for instance, women are no longer expected to wear corsets when they go bicycling. (See Patricia Campbell Warner, When the Girls Came Out to Play, The Birth of American Sportswear, 2006, pp. 119-121.) It was indeed a different world.

There is today, however, a strong countervailing force that did not exist in the 1890s, which boils down to inertia. After a century of dominance by the car industry, people are used to things the way they are. To a very large extent, the general public and our institutions simply don't have a great interest in changing things on our streets. 

The Vision Zero initiative is useful in this regard, and I have seen some shifts. Not so long ago, a fellow who was president of a local community organization in Philadelphia told me that he thought 35,000 dead on America's roads and streets every year was a reasonable cost of doing business. I haven't heard that line recently. Instead, people seem to have retreated to denial: The numbers are wrong. They don't reflect what we see on our street every day. This is, of course, lunacy, but given the way things have been going in this country, I'm not sure it's going away any time soon. 

Traffic fatalities reached 42,915 in 2021. 

Philadelphia has a particular problem in its city hall, where I sense a profound entropy. When I look at city hall these days, I find myself thinking about an aging octopus, no longer fully in control of its tentacles, given to long naps and disorientation upon awakening. This syndrome seems to have enveloped the last several mayors, city council for as long as I can remember, and young staffers who quietly ask themselves if this is the way things are supposed to be.

Let's look at the city bureaucracy. Recently, I have heard that the Streets department in Philadelphia may, as an entity, be moving away from its fierce, if largely passive aggressive, resistance to bicycles. I'm going to wait and see on this one.

And there is substantial resistance to bicycling among some members of the general public. Part of this seems to be a simple, and very human, dislike of change. This can be paired with an automatic dislike of people who are not exactly like you. And if those people have different needs from yours, then that can be another catalyst for opposition. 

In addition, I've found that there seems to be an unwillingness to see bicyclists as they actually are. One of the most common misconceptions I run into is the idea that bicycling is still almost entirely about leisure. That simply is not true in Philadelphia today. As we saw in the bike racks around Civic Center Boulevard, there's a lot of bike commuting. Beyond commuting, there's utility biking that takes place throughout the course of the day -  taking kids to school (and home again), shopping, visiting Aunt Tillie - oh, and yes, delivering food. Bicycling - and scooting - have been integrated into the fabric of the city's life. 

Finally, we need to look at the people in the shadows behind the people. They've learned how to coopt community organizing and use it for their own ends. A good example is the recent fiasco on Washington Avenue, where community groups were essentially pawns of the local business establishment, and the folks in city hall were happy to play along. {For two stories on Washington Avenue, click here and here.)

This approach is qualitatively different from the more traditional approach that has its roots in the advertising industry - controlling people's minds to sell them a product or a candidate. Essentially the people pulling the strings have adopted the tactics of the left. This shift has been underway for a while. I remember, back in the 1990s, there was a push in the corporate world to develop their "grassroots." I don't believe this went well, because employees kept showing up at political events wearing polo shirts with the company logo. And people started referring to "astroturf." 

The new system, on the other hand, clearly works, and we can see examples of it all around us. I invariably find it sad to watch people being exploited in this manner, but it works, and I don't think it's going away any time soon.

Wednesday, January 25, 2023

Ron DeSantis Comes to Philly

And the Mighty Union League Stumbles


Poor Ron DeSantis, who really wants to be Benito Mussolini, got a warm reception on January 24, during an ill-considered visit to Philadelphia. I don't think it hurt DeSantis much, but I think the Union League is not going to have an easy time crawling back from this humiliation. 

There were actually two protest rallies in front of the League building on Broad street, two blocks from City Hall, and just across Moravian street from the building that, years ago, housed the Philadelphia Stock Exchange. The first rally began at noon and lasted about an hour. The second began at 4 pm and extended into the evening, with a dwindling but enthusiastic contingent of pickets.

For me, the protests felt a bit like a reunion. I found some people I hadn't seen since before the pandemic, and I met some new people. It's fun rallying in front of the League. And the building is so photogenic.


I also have memories of being inside. I ate there several times, many years ago. The food was profoundly old-fashioned. They even had succotash, which is a mixture of lima beans and corn. 

And here I was again, as darkness came over the city, standing on a picket line in front of the Union League, which at this point was protected by a long barricade of bicycle racks. The League members on their way to visit with Florida's governor had to walk along the sidewalk behind the barricade and then proceed up the steps to the main door on the second floor. They'd had to park at the Bellevue, a hotel in the next block, and they weren't wearing overcoats, and a few of the women were actually shivering.

Some of the protesters said they felt like they were watching a perp walk. And perhaps they were.

Oh well. So many clubs have died in Philadelphia. I'd hate to see the Union League building knocked down, but frankly the club just bet the farm on a turkey.


(For a story in BillyPenn, click here. For an opinion piece in the Inquirer, click here.)

See also And So the Worm Turned, On Demagogues.

Tuesday, January 3, 2023

Up in the Air and Down on the Ground

Downtown Brooklyn's Flatbush Avenue Booms

Flatbush in the sky.


If you haven't been to downtown Brooklyn lately, you're in for a shock. In 2009, the last time I ran the New York City Marathon, the tallest thing near the intersection of Flatbush and Fulton was the Williamsburgh Savings Bank Tower. In fact, it was the tallest building in Brooklyn, and had been since it opened in 1929. Today, there is a whole bevy of buildings in the neighborhood that top out above the Williamsburgh Savings Bank. 

Foremost among them is the first supertall skyscraper in Brooklyn, currently known as the Brooklyn Tower. You can see it lurking quietly in the back of the picture above. (A supertall skyscraper is more than 300 meters, or 984 feet, tall.) 

All this redevelopment flows from a 2004 rezoning of the area, designed to reinforce downtown Brooklyn as New York's third major downtown, after Midtown and Lower Manhattan. What's actually happening, though, is less about increasing office space and more about providing more apartments, both condominium and rental. The Brooklyn Tower, for instance, plans to sell about 150 condos and rent an additional 425 apartments.

Here's another look at the Brooklyn Tower, from Flatbush. 


All this redevelopment is not limited to Flatbush Avenue. Let's take a few steps down Fulton to Ashland, where we have the building below.


I think this is my favorite of all the new buildings that have gone up in this area.

I do enjoy looking at these sculptures in the sky. It's something of a guilty pleasure for me, because I think there is a tendency for all of us to say, first, that the building looks great from the outside, and, second, that the views realtors can show to prospective tenants are spectacular, and then call it a day.

But what about a guy walking down the street? What is my experience at ground level? Let's go back to the Brooklyn Tower. Here's a shot of the street facade, which was still under construction when I took the picture last summer.


There were a lot of construction barriers in this neighborhood last summer, along with a lot of construction vehicles, so I don't think it would be right to judge the planned street experience until it's fully in place. I will say I'm hopeful. The Fulton Street mall is only a few feet from the Brooklyn Tower. It's a pedestrian-priority shopping street and a very enjoyable experience. 

The Traffic on Flatbush

All we need to do, in my view, is extend that experience onto Flatbush. And there's the rub. The traffic on Flatbush is nightmarish. It comes pouring off the Manhattan Bridge and flows like a torrent in spring directly down Flatbush towards Grand Army Plaza, at the tip of Prospect Park, and to points beyond. Along the way it interacts with a number of cross streets, most notably Atlantic Avenue, another nightmarish urban highway.

NYCDOT (the New York City Department of Transportation) has been doing a variety of things to try to calm the traffic on Flatbush and generally make for a more pleasant pedestrian experience. As you can see in the photo, there are plantings in the well-armored raised median. At the end of each block there is a waiting area for pedestrians - perhaps not an island, but a peninsula -  also well armored.  (For some interesting work-in-progress photos, click here. For pictures of the completed pedestrian refuges, click here.)

NYCDOT has also been doing what it can to rationalize vehicular traffic. One of my favorite changes was elimination of the left-hand turn across traffic at Myrtle, which I had to negotiate when coming to Fort Greene from the Manhattan Bridge. I'm much happier with the right-hand turn that takes you onto a little stub of Myrtle that stops at Brooklyn Commons Park. You then do a 180 and drive straight across Flatbush and into Fort Greene. (Until very recently, Brooklyn Commons was called MetroTech Center. For a story, click here.)

Hoarding Art

If we can go back to the ground-level photo of the Brooklyn Tower. Allow me to guide you through one of my pet peeves. Have a look at the plywood sheets fencing off the construction area. The British call these construction barriers hoardings. In the past these generally became the home of many, many advertising posters. (I'm particularly remembering circus posters for some reason.) Nowadays it seems these placards have gone away, and in their place we have - green paint. At least at the Brooklyn Tower.

If you go a few blocks away, near the Brooklyn Academy of Music (BAM), you can see the possibility of these surfaces. 


This effort strikes me as less orderly and more whimsical than green plywood. I like that.

While we're in the BAM neighborhood, let's have a look at something a bit more formal. This, believe it or not, is a bike rack in an empty lot. You lock onto the letters. It's called the BAM Bike Park, and you can read a little more about it by clicking here. 


The BAM neighborhood is an interesting transitional space between the high-rises on Flatbush and the low-rise brownstone belt - a lovely gift from the nineteenth century, when this part of Brooklyn became a home for the prosperous middle class. 

Other parts of the Flatbush area treat the small streets behind them as their backside, creating more of a no man's zone than a transitional area. Small streets that deserve better are relegated to exhaust louvers from ventilation systems, entrances to garages, and large plastic bags of garbage coming out of back doors.

But I come with a message of hope. Look at this picture, which is on Hudson just off of DeKalb.


NEWS FLASH: Service alleys don't have to be disgusting. They can even, if only intermittently, be fun. You want safe streets? You want happy streets? Put people on the street. They don't have to be two handsome young cops with a clown car. But it is a nice picture. I'm fond of it.

The Brownstone Belt

One of the great things about Flatbush is you're never very far from the brownstone belt. Because it's older, and it's seen a bit more of the world than its new neighbors on Flatbush, I think it is more open to experiment, trying different things. Maybe it's a bit more like the BAM transitional area, or maybe it just has its own approach to the world. Here's what hoarding art looks like in the brownstone belt.


The openness even extends to dogs. I ran into this little fellow outside a coffee shop on the Open Streets section of Willoughby. I've never seen a canine hitching post quite like the one he's tied to, so I thought I'd share. File it under street furniture.



Fort Greene Park

As the last stop on our little walking tour, we come to Fort Greene Park, for a lesson on monumentality from 1908. The tall column in the foreground is a memorial to the prison ship martyrs - thousands of Americans died near here during the Revolutionary War. The British were housing American prisoners on old ships parked in Wallabout Bay, which is where the Navy Yard is currently located. They died like flies from massive overcrowding, poor nutrition, lousy sanitation, and resultant disease. 

You'll notice Brooklyn's first supertall lurking in the background. I think the vertical striations on the supertall go well with the column's fluting.


So, yes, architects were doing cool stuff up in the air more than a century ago. But McKim, Mead, and White, the architects here, also paid careful attention to the ground level. Have a look at the eagle below. You can look him in the eye. I find myself a bit unsettled whenever I do so, which to me is a sign of good art. 



There are actually four of these eagles, marking the corners of the plaza from which the memorial column rises. So when you get tired of craning your neck trying to take in all of the memorial column, you can shift your gaze down to ground level and hang out with these bronze birds. (For more on the monument and the eagles, click here.)

See also Lafayette, We Were There; Fitting the Solution to the Problem; Transit Memories; South Portland Avenue, Brooklyn; Flexible Vanderbilt; Of Planters and Whimsy.

Sunday, December 4, 2022

Bluestone to the Rescue!

Every Street Needs a Gimmick


Have a look at the street in the picture above. It's really narrow, and it's surrounded by some pretty high buildings. Philadelphia has a bunch of streets like this. It's an old city. 

I see a lot of potential in these narrow streets with high walls. There's a lot of intrinsic drama here.

Years ago, narrow streets were a thing. Then along came the mania for wide streets - really wide streets - and people stopped paying much attention to the little ones. 

The street above is in the 2300 block of Ludlow, just south of Market and not far from the Market Street bridge. I think a lot of people don't even know it's there. It's easy to miss as you drive by on 23rd street.

Outdoor Rooms

It's not that people don't know about Philly's narrow streets, but I think it's fair to say that the picture which comes immediately to mind is something like Elfreth's Alley - a small residential street flanked by relatively low buildings.

Streets like Elfreth's Alley have the potential to be outdoor rooms. Here's a picture of Smedley street running north from Pine to Spruce. Smedley lies between 16th and 17th.


Not every little residential street looks like this, of course. But some do, and more could.

Most of these streets are lined with small dwellings that are two or three stories tall, and I think the low height of the buildings contributes mightily to the feeling of an outdoor room.

Urbanist Jan Gehl, in his Cities for People (2010), has interesting things to say about how people on a street relate to the buildings that line the street. He notes that humans are designed to look primarily horizontally, and down. Looking up is not so easy for us. We can readily take in the first two or three stories of a building; and we can with more difficulty relate effectively up to about five floors. (See, in particular, pages 39-42, 84.) 

Imagine you're trying to talk to someone leaning out a window. Fairly easy if the person is on the second or third floor; up to five stories you can probably still connect. Higher floors are essentially disconnected from the ground, or, as Gehl puts it on page 42, "Above the fifth floor, offices and housing should logically be the province of the air-traffic control authorities." 

With a three-story building the cornice at the top can signal the ceiling, which of course isn't there. Instead we have a room where the sky stands in for the ceiling.

Narrow Streets, High Walls

Higher walls create something different. I've been calling these narrow streets with high walls concrete canyons (to borrow a term from Manhattan). There are two basic things going on here: First, compression at the street level and, second, an invitation to look up - straight up at a sliver of the sky.

There's an old Latin epigram - per aspera ad astra. Here's a translation: Through difficulties we reach for the stars. 

So the compression on the ground reminds us of the limitations we face in our daily lives. And the sliver of the sky reminds us that we have higher aspirations.

Not a bad lesson for a street to teach. I suppose we could call such a street an open-air cathedral.

Medieval Gothic cathedrals, in particular, work this effect very well. For instance, the cathedral at Chartres in northern France has a nave that is 37 meters tall - about 120 feet. Not too shabby for a building built out of stone. And then there are the stained glass windows, particularly those high up, in the clerestory. 

I suspect that streets like 2300 Ludlow are probably cathedrals of commerce, and I don't expect them to match the effect of Chartres, but the compression at ground level and the invitation to crank our necks back and look straight up are the same.

We have quite a few streets in Philly that pull this off with aplomb. A few years ago I found a happy hunting ground of sorts in Old City, north of Chestnut and west of Second. Here's a picture of Strawberry street, with the Custom House in the background. You will notice the truck, which gives you a good idea of the width of the street, and also the trash bins and a rather pensive man standing in the road. 


These are working streets, with delivery trucks bringing stuff in and trash trucks hauling stuff out. There's even the occasional car.

This block, as you can see, is blessed with quite a number of front facades. However, in many of these little streets, you are looking primarily at the back or the side of buildings. This is definitely true of 2300 Ludlow, but I have some good news. 

The new building going up in the 2300 block of Market will take up the whole block from 23rd to 24th, and extending to Ludlow. However, it will not be demolishing the large building at 23rd street, which has lovely facades on Market, 23rd and Ludlow. It will be incorporated into the new building. So the facades you see below, on 23rd and Ludlow, will remain, along with a similar facade on Market.


The Blank Wall Problem

I think our new open-air cathedral will have a very nice north wall. As for the south wall, I think it's time to say, with the astronauts of Apollo 13, "Houston, we have a problem." 

The building on the south side of the street is primarily a parking garage with some offices, none of which open onto Ludlow. What we have on Ludlow is a blank wall extending from the ground to the sky, punctuated by openings that allow the tailpipe emissions to dissipate.

We have a lot of these blank garage walls in Philadelphia, and they share one thing - they're very boring. There's basically nothing to look at.

It's possible to make them less boring. One option is throw a fabric screen over the whole thing. Then you can illustrate in any way you want. Here is a small-scale screen fronting a construction site on Sansom at 16th.


I'm more partial to paint on masonry, as in the picture below. This garage is at 12th and Walnut.


Not boring. Think of the people in the new building on the north side of Ludlow. The new building will have lots of windows looking out to the garage, and the people inside the building will be glancing out the window occasionally. We don't want them to be bored to death. Perhaps we could even amuse them.

At Ground Level

My main concern, however, is for the people walking by at ground level. What will this canyon feel like to someone on the street?

Remember that we humans spend most of our time looking horizontally, or a little bit down. The walls at the ground floor are therefore crucial to the pedestrian's experience. So how much variety in the ground-floor visual experience do we need?

Jan Gehl says that, on commercial streets, the ideal width for a storefront is around 19 feet. (Gehl visited Philadelphia in 2016 and walked Market Street from Old City to City Hall with Ashley Hahn of WHYY's PlanPhilly. For the resulting story, click here.)

It's easier to meet this goal on a commercial block that has a string of small shops. That's why the shopping areas on Walnut and Chestnut are more successful than the commercial frontages on Market and JFK.  

Not every street is going to be lined by shops, or interesting residential facades, but the pedestrian's need to be amused is a constant, and walkers will tend to walk where they know they will find interesting things to look at. How do we keep people interested when they're walking down a block like 2300 Ludlow?

I don't foresee anyone opening a trendy boutique here. I expect that this will always be mainly a space that people pass through, rather than a place where people linger. But still I think it should be a space that people enjoy passing through, and possibly even remember fondly.

One thing not to do is put up a blank wall. Unfortunately, this seems to be an acceptable solution for at least some architects and developers in Philadelphia today. Here's a nearby wall on a relatively new building that's even blanker than the parking garage. This one is in the 2200 block of Ranstead, barely a stone's throw from 2300 Ludlow. 


Even the decrepit north side of Ludlow is doing better than this. Have a look below.


You may not like this assemblage very much, but I'm a pushover for ramshackle. 

Just as a reminder of the potential that these spaces have, here's a picture of a facade on Bank Street, in Old City.


This of course is an actual building facade, but architects have a whole footlocker full of ornaments that can dress up a blank wall. My favorite is the pilaster, which dates back to ancient Greece. Such ornaments have generally fallen out of favor.

As with the upper floors discussed above, my go-to solution for the Blank Wall Problem at street-level is a mural, which is also an ornament. However, in Philly at least, murals seem to have gained some acceptance, and they do save you from what may be the only alternate solution, which is to completely redesign whatever is behind the blank wall and add some windows and possibly a door or two - in other words, to create an actual facade.

I've given the matter some thought, and I think the dreadfully boring ground-level wall on the south side of 2300 Ludlow needs a mural. Not just any mural. As a street-level mural, it needs a lot of detail, and a lot of different things going on, and, I think, people.  For this particular site, I think the mural should be an imaginary streetscape from around 1900, complete with pushcart vendors and happy merchants standing in the doorways of their shops. Maybe a cat snoozing in a shop window. A few well-behaved dogs, children playing with hoops, perhaps a mother selecting apples from a pushcart while holding her baby in her arm (motherhood could be complicated even then).

A Room with a Floor

Why all this nostalgia? Let's have a look at the third piece of our cathedral - the floor.

On one of my early visits to this block, I noticed that the asphalt pavement was badly deteriorated, and then I noticed, peeking out of the holes in the blacktop, something remarkable: bluestone pavers.


Under the tarmac, it turned out, was a whole city block of old bluestone pavement, suitably mangled by the ravages of time. And I thought to myself: "What a fabulous gimmick!" A bluestone street. I know of only one intact bluestone street in the larger Rittenhouse area. It's in the 1400 block of Waverly, behind Peirce College. Perhaps we could daylight the bluestone in 2300 Ludlow and restore the inevitable defects. Then the area would have two bluestone streets.

Here's a shot of 1400 Waverly.


And here's a close-up of some of the bluestone. You'll note there are a few red bricks, presumably filling in for damaged bluestone.


I think bluestone is gorgeous, providing an attractive and unusual backdrop for the surrounding red walls, and also giving us a little history lesson: Years ago, our city looked very different, often in ways that are now hard to imagine.

If it's not possible to restore the bluestone pavement on 2300 Ludlow, perhaps it would be possible to salvage the viable bluestone at that location and use it to replace some of the red bricks currently being used in the 1400 block of Waverly. I actually like the red bricks, but I would love to see a bluestone street in close to its original state.

________

ALAS, my bluestone proposals have been overtaken by events. This block of Ludlow was recently repaved with asphalt, and the bluestone pavers will sleep again under the asphalt, for a few more years.

See also Second and Chestnut, This Isn't Just Any Alley, Gordon Cullen and the Outdoor Floor, Small Streets Are Like Diamonds,  A Few Deft Touches for Back Streets, Buried Under the Tarmac.