Tuesday, November 17, 2026

"But we're still in charge!"

Uh, no.

James Bradley.


I've been thinking about James Bradley, who founded Asbury Park, N.J., in 1871 and is apparently no relation to Bill Bradley, who played basketball for Princeton and the New York Knicks and also served as a United States senator from New Jersey.

James Bradley was a businessman in New York City who did very well during the Civil War by making brushes for the Union army. After the war he was looking for new horizons. A devout methodist, he attended the new camp meeting the methodists had set up in a little place on the Jersey shore that they called Ocean Grove. (And yes, they still have trees, and they still have tents. And the ocean is still there.)

Bradley liked Ocean Grove, and he noticed the area to the north was a virtual wilderness. To make a long story short, James bought a large parcel of land just north of Ocean Grove and proceeded to build a beach town that he christened Asbury Park, after one of the founders of methodism in the United States. (It's my understanding that Heck street in Asbury Park is named after Barbara Heck, known as the "mother of American methodism." I'll stop now.) 

So how did Asbury Park turn into a party town known for rock & roll and a certain, shall we say, live and let live approach to life?

It took a while. Bradley was used to running a brush factory, and when he told people to do something, he expected them to do it. As the city grew, the people living there became less and less likely to actually follow his orders.

This seemed to bewilder Bradley. Eventually he lost his unilateral control of the town, and in the end, of course, he died.

I do have a little sympathy for Bradley. He had grown up in a world where there were the bosses and the little people, and he was a boss. Even though he helped the Union win the civil war, which was about freedom for all people, he seems never to have accepted the idea that freedom for all people might affect his control over Asbury Park.

I spent decades working for large corporations, and the mentality I saw matches pretty well with Bradley's approach. The head of one of those corporations loved to tell people, "This is not a democracy."

And indeed corporations are not democracies. But the United States is a democracy - at least for now. There is a tension there.

Until recently, the tide had seemed to be flowing against democracy. Of course, the thought that the people with money should run things is a recurrent idea in American history, but since the Reagan administration the people at the top have accumulated a simply mind-boggling amount of money. In their comfortable bubble, they issue orders to their lackeys, and the lackeys scurry off to make it so.

And so we have people like Stephen Miller shouting orders, expecting to be obeyed. It's all very Prussian.

But we are not Prussians. We are Americans, and we are tired of being ruled by oligarchs and their servants. And many people are not just tired of the Rs. They're tired of the Ds, as well.

Many people have been saying for years that there's no difference between the two parties. I don't agree, but I understand their point of view.

What I would say is that the people currently running both parties are beholden to oligarchs. It's possible that our oligarchs are nicer than their oligarchs, and it's possible our politicians, in contrast with the Rs, actually mean well and are attempting to balance the demands of their oligarchs with the demands of the people.

Call me a radical, but that does not get to the root of the problem, which is oligarchy. Let's go back to James Bradley, who lived in a world of bosses and little people. Years ago, a professor suggested that dividing us all into leaders and followers was a simplistic idea that didn't mesh well with the modern world. He suggested that we all needed to, at various times, be leaders, followers, or colleagues, and we needed to be adept at shifting from one role to another.

There are, of course, more complicated models, but this one has stuck with me.

And it's an idea that clearly horrifies many people who are currently in positions of power. But our leaders do not own their jobs. 

And maybe we need leaders who are not beholden to oligarchs, because the basic challenge we face is the role of oligarchs in our society.

If you have a subscription to the New York Times, you may want to read Bradley's obituary. (He was a control freak.)

See also Nero, There's Got to Be a Better Way, Fixing the Constitution, Andy Kim Gives Me Hope, How the Dam Breaks, Somotomo, Unleashing the Oligarchs.

For more on the history of beach towns, see The Wreck of the New Era, Layers at the Beach Front, The Uncertain Eighties, Umbrellaville.

No comments:

Post a Comment