These events just keep getting better.
Philadelphia's Center City District had a string of West Walnut Open Streets this fall, running every Sunday from September 13 through October 25. I was only able to make it to the last one, and boy am I glad I did.
I think the secret of these open streets is to please both the merchants and the people. From the look of things, it seems that the West Walnut program is quite successful at both. The Center City District collects data on this topic, and I expect that the numbers will be quite satisfactory.
It does help to have some music. (Also a reminder that Moravian does not have to be a trash alley. It's our choice.)
The next challenge is to appeal to a broad range of people - not just one demographic.
I think chalk appeals to all ages, but I also think children have a whole-body enthusiasm for it, while more mature people may be more cautious in our approach. But, as they say in the circus, fun for children of all ages.
Ping-pong, or table tennis, can actually be a whole family activity.
Is there anything we can do for dog owners that we're not already doing?
Innovations
There were a couple of things on October 25 that were new to me. One was the mini-farmers' market on Walnut, next to the park in Rittenhouse Square. On Saturday, of course, there is a very large farmers' market in this location (there's also a smaller version on Tuesdays).
I think there may have been a hesitation to allow street vendors, possibly with the concern that they would take business away from the restaurants and stores in the area. I think the solution here was to offer stuff that none of the permanent stores were offering.
Also new was a mini-soccer pitch.
And here we have what may have been the hit of the show - at least for the kids: a portable kind of miniature golf.
Maximizing use of the space
I always look for improvement opportunities. These would be ways to flesh out the basic concept, which is very different from the crowded street markets that Philly knows and loves.
I've mentioned the need to please both the merchants and the people, and the need to appeal to a broad range of people. Also, as a practical matter, I think it would be nice to fill the whole space allotted to the program, and also to fill the whole time. Putting one of these open streets on is a big deal, and you want to use the space well for all the time allotted.
So, how are we doing on the last two items: fully occupy the space, and fully occupy the time?
As for fully occupying the space, I think we still have a challenge with the 1400 block of Walnut, which butts up against Broad street. There are some very nice buildings on this block, including the Bellevue hotel; some of the buildings here are very big.
I'm usually pretty busy when I'm walking on this block; in particular, the car traffic on 15th on an ordinary day is, shall we say, very distracting. With the cars muzzled, I noticed that I was feeling this block was very dark. I gave away my last light meter years ago, but I do have the sense that this block is substantially darker than the ones further west.
The center of gravity for this event will always be to the west, at 18th and Walnut. But the block by the Bellevue, facing Broad street, needs to be a gateway. It needs to be an inviting gateway.
The urbanist Jan Gehl likes to talk about The Invitation. (See Jan Gehl, Cities for People, 2010, pp. 15, 17, 21, 236-237.) In this context, what is the way in, and why would I want to go there? I don't have the answers for Walnut and Broad. But I would start with making the area brighter. (Maybe cleaning some of the facades might help.)
As for filling the time, I don't think we have any significant problems in the afternoon. When the staff start to clear the space, they're careful not to disturb anyone who wants to linger a bit more. So you have them taking away three tables and leaving one, and everybody seems just fine with that. (They will eventually ask you to leave.)
My concern has been with the morning. The event starts at ten on a Sunday morning, and frankly there aren't a lot of people around Rittenhouse square who are out and about at that time.
But there is one group: parents with small children. And Open Streets has something for them: the Bubble Man. The bubble man makes soap bubbles - really big soap bubbles, and really, really big clouds of small bubbles - all while he's surrounded by a circle of children in strollers, along with parents who are very happy to have something to do on a Sunday morning.
I visited the October 25 event twice - once at the start in the morning, and again in the late afternoon. As I was leaving from my morning visit, I passed a family with two parents and two children in a double stroller. I said, "Don't miss the bubble man!" The father smiled - actually he grinned - and he said, "We're headed there right now."
No comments:
Post a Comment