Tuesday, June 9, 2015

Parking Permits and Musical Chairs

A few years ago, the Beacon Hill neighborhood in Boston set what I hope is a record. Beacon Hill is a prosperous residential neighborhood near the central business district. It's quite compact; there are only 983 on-street parking spaces. Residents with parking permits had the exclusive use of these spaces. The city issued the permits for free.

So how many of these parking permits were there? 3,933, or four for every spot.

I have this story from Professor Donald Shoup (The High Cost of Free Parking, 2011 edition, p. 516 and footnotes 31 and 32 on p. 552). After I read it, I started to wonder about the number of active parking permits in my neighborhood in Philadelphia, which is covered by residential parking permit Zone 1.

My neighborhood is essentially the southwest quadrant of William Penn's original plan for the city, centered on Rittenhouse Square. Sometimes it's called Greater Rittenhouse. I've taken to calling it CCRAville, after the Center City Residents' Association, the local civic group.

CCRAville extends south to South Street, but Zone 1 keeps going all the way down to Washington Avenue. The South of South Neighborhood Association looks after the area from South Street to Washington Avenue, which I call SOSNAland.

Both of these groups have recently performed parking inventories. CCRAville found 1,584 Zone 1 spots. SOSNAland, which is larger,  found 2,103. So there are 3,687 Zone 1 parking spaces in Zone 1.

And how many parking permits are currently in effect? Take a guess. Go ahead. Get a piece of paper and write your number down.

Okay. I filled out yet another Right to Know request and sent it off to the Philadelphia Parking Authority. A few days later they sent me a note saying they needed a little more time, and a few days after that they sent me the numbers.

As I've said before, I've found my recent interactions with the PPA to be productive and even pleasant. (There was that parking ticket six years ago.)

There are 6,957 Zone 1 parking permits currently active -- roughly two permits for every available Zone 1 spot.

How does that compare to your guess? Were you higher, or lower? Perhaps I influenced you with my story about Beacon Hill. Or maybe you couldn't believe a government agency would invite 12 people to play musical chairs when there were only six chairs.

Where Are the Extra Cars Parked?
One interesting question is where all those extra sticker owners are parking. I think the Beacon Hill story can give us some guidance here. Professor Shoup reports that in 2004 the price of a condominium parking space on Beacon Hill was as high as $167,500 (plus a monthly condo fee and annual property tax). Professor Shoup calculates the annual cost of one of these spots as $11,000. People are willing to pay a lot to be sure of a space.

By contrast, here in Philly in 2015 there is a garage a block from my house that charges $250 a month, or $3,000 a year. I've always thought that was kind of expensive, but it depends on what you compare it to -- $11,000 in Boston, or $35 at the curb in Philadelphia.

At any rate, Mike Axler and I have shown that at least 87 percent of households in CCRAville are not parking on the street in their neighborhood.

Why would you buy a sticker and never use it? The answer is that you can use it occasionally.  Every once in a while there's an open spot on my block. If I know I'm going out again in an hour, I may park at the curb instead of putting the car away in the garage. It doesn't happen very often. But it's only $35.

Splitting Zone 1
There's a proposal to split Zone 1 at South Street, so SOSNAland and CCRAville would each have their own parking zones. SOSNAland seems to feel that some of its congestion issues come from CCRAvillers parking south of South. I'm inclined to agree that this happens, but I have no way to size the phenomenon.  Personally I'm in favor of the proposal because I think it would make it easier to raise the price of a parking sticker in CCRAville. (There's no particular reason why all the zones in the city should have the same permit price, and yet they do.)

As part of my request to PPA, I asked for a breakout of the number of Zone 1 permits held by residents living in each of the two proposed zones. I combined those numbers with the number of spots in each area to produce these two tables.

CCRAville
Total on-street spots - 3,161
Zone 1 spots - 1,584
Zone 1 permits - 3,863

SOSNAland
Total on-street spots - 4,884
Zone 1 spots - 2,103
Zone 1 permits - 3,121

As you can see, CCRAville has 2,000 more stickers than Zone 1 spots, and it seems likely that some of them are parking south of South, although I think the bulk of them are parking off-street.

On the other hand SOSNAland, on its own, has 1,000 more stickers than Zone 1 spots. So splitting Zone 1 into two pieces will not be a panacea. There still won't be enough Zone 1 parking spaces for all the permit holders.

But wait -- SOSNAland is blessed with quite a few parking spaces that are not Zone 1 -- or at least not yet. There are 2,781 of these spots. Some of them are two-hour spots, which means they're not suitable for long-term storage, although they're a good place to park overnight. Many of the spots, though, are uncontrolled -- anybody can park for as long as he or she wants.

The uncontrolled blocks are often completely filled with parked cars. Who owns them? Once again, residents tend to point to outsiders -- for instance, Penn and Drexel students who bring their cars to school and store them for extended periods. I expect this happens, but again I have no way to size the phenomenon.

What if the vast majority of people parking in these uncontrolled spots are actually residents of SOSNAland -- Zone 1 permit holders who can't find a Zone 1 spot, and other residents who choose not to buy a Zone 1 permit?

It would be good to know who's parking there. If you convert these blocks to Zone 1 status, and the people currently parking there either have Zone 1 permits or can easily buy one, then you have gone to a considerable effort and made precisely no progress in controlling parking congestion.

This brings us to an important lesson: Parking permit zones are good at excluding outsiders. When the problem is too many insiders, things get complicated.

17 comments:

  1. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon the blog and wished to say that I’ve truly enjoyed browsing the blog posts.Direct Office Solutions

    ReplyDelete
  2. Parking software condominium

    “Why security firms use web parking software for parking enforcement, parking violations and parking management”
    World-wide-web solutions in a group retain the most important data fiscal information and other very sensitive and exclusive information will be transported and located. Property or home Operators condo supervisors, Panel Associates, professional property or home and linked to overseeing was able car parking setting.
    You need dependable, progressive in addition to successful software program to handle your current businesses auto parking in addition to customer passes. You desire a built-in process that enables to be able to easily tracking check in addition to alter exactly where persons park your car in addition to have. Entrance functions achieve all this together with effective however convenient to use process agreed upon to guarantee the safety measures of your campus in addition to lots. A era your current campus lots auto parking structure sub-sections together with custom made place assignments, Car or truck Registration together with in decal allocation in addition to rebirth procedure, Auto parking Citations in addition to accounts receivable functions.

    ReplyDelete
  3. text message to tenants

    Free Parking Software for Town Houses, Condominiums, and Businesses Solves Parking Problems
    Searching for a parking space is such as frustrating routine activity for lots of people in cities all over the world. This search is burning over a million barrels of oil of the world each day. There are also 4-parking spaces every vehicle in the US and almost all streets are most of the time, empty, which leads to urban environments that are ironically doing far more to accommodate the vehicles than people. As the global population continuously urbanize, without a convenience-driven and well-planned retreat from cars, these sort of parking problems will worsen.
    http://webparkingsoftware.com software is the first step in the right decision. It involves using low-cost sensors, mobile phone-enabled, and real time data collection automated payment systems enabling people to reserve parking in advance or predict accurately where they can find a spot. When deployed as a system, free parking software thereby reduces car emissions in the urban centers by means of reducing the necessity for the people to circle the city blocks needlessly searching for parking. Furthermore, it permits the cities to manage their parking supply carefully.
    This free parking software is now being developed in many different states and cities around the United States and some other countries. For instance, in LA, smart meters and low-power sensors are tracking the occupancy of parking spaces across the Hollywood district, one of the most congested areas. The users will be able to access this occupancy data in order to determine the availability of the spots and then pay for them with their mobile phones. Other than the environmental benefits and lending convenience, free parking software is improving the utilization of the current parking, which lead to greater revenue for parking owners.
    These programs will be able to make great differences on a neighborhood level, but more widespread development and deployment is necessary for free parking software to change the cities and to contribute to the transportation sector pollution reductions greenhouse gas. One problem is that there are no citywide solutions all over the fragmented private and public parking providers. The occupancy data has a tendency to have many owners and is not accessible or standardized in a way that may enable software developers to turn into user-friendly applications. Thereby, individual smart parking efforts are so far successful locally, but uncoordinated, and operates in their own entrepreneurial or bureaucratic vacuums without a need to take gap between current free parking software and more widespread transportation system planning is an enormous missed opportunity for the cities to reduce the transportation related emissions.
    Moreover, free parking software has been hindered by a lack of insight into the complete benefits of this software, specifically when compared to the cost of building extra parking spaces. Lack of collaboration between communities with the parking software programs, as well as lack of coordination between hardware providers, municipalities, and developers is also contributing to the slower adoption of smart parking. Nevertheless, it is possible to overcome all these issues. Cities will be able further accelerate these advantages by means of updating the land use and building codes policies to reflect the reduced need for parking.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Parking Management Software

    Free Parking Software for Town Houses, Condominiums, and Businesses Solves Parking Problems
    Searching for a parking space is such as frustrating routine activity for lots of people in cities all over the world. This search is burning over a million barrels of oil of the world each day. There are also 4-parking spaces every vehicle in the US and almost all streets are most of the time, empty, which leads to urban environments that are ironically doing far more to accommodate the vehicles than people. As the global population continuously urbanize, without a convenience-driven and well-planned retreat from cars, these sort of parking problems will worsen.
    http://webparkingsoftware.com software is the first step in the right decision. It involves using low-cost sensors, mobile phone-enabled, and real time data collection automated payment systems enabling people to reserve parking in advance or predict accurately where they can find a spot. When deployed as a system, free parking software thereby reduces car emissions in the urban centers by means of reducing the necessity for the people to circle the city blocks needlessly searching for parking. Furthermore, it permits the cities to manage their parking supply carefully.
    This free parking software is now being developed in many different states and cities around the United States and some other countries. For instance, in LA, smart meters and low-power sensors are tracking the occupancy of parking spaces across the Hollywood district, one of the most congested areas. The users will be able to access this occupancy data in order to determine the availability of the spots and then pay for them with their mobile phones. Other than the environmental benefits and lending convenience, free parking software is improving the utilization of the current parking, which lead to greater revenue for parking owners.
    These programs will be able to make great differences on a neighborhood level, but more widespread development and deployment is necessary for free parking software to change the cities and to contribute to the transportation sector pollution reductions greenhouse gas. One problem is that there are no citywide solutions all over the fragmented private and public parking providers. The occupancy data has a tendency to have many owners and is not accessible or standardized in a way that may enable software developers to turn into user-friendly applications. Thereby, individual smart parking efforts are so far successful locally, but uncoordinated, and operates in their own entrepreneurial or bureaucratic vacuums without a need to take gap between current free parking software and more widespread transportation system planning is an enormous missed opportunity for the cities to reduce the transportation related emissions.
    Moreover, free parking software has been hindered by a lack of insight into the complete benefits of this software, specifically when compared to the cost of building extra parking spaces. Lack of collaboration between communities with the parking software programs, as well as lack of coordination between hardware providers, municipalities, and developers is also contributing to the slower adoption of smart parking. Nevertheless, it is possible to overcome all these issues. Cities will be able further accelerate these advantages by means of updating the land use and building codes policies to reflect the reduced need for parking.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Zubaidas Online Provide Complete Range of Furniture Buy Online in Karachi, Lahore, Islamabad All Across Pakistan
    baby furniture for sale online

    ReplyDelete
  6. We take the frustration out of parking management for Apartments, Home Owners Associations, Condominiums, Townhouses Co-ops, and other parking areas.Webparkingsoftware.com has reinvented how parking management should be done. Our software was built from the ground up for: Property Managers, Apartment Managers, Board members, Commercial property and anyone involved in overseeing a managed parking environment.

    Some features include:

    • Full Parking Management System for any size building
    • Issue professional parking permits
    • Assign parking spaces for tenants
    • Allocate guest parking and special event parking
    • Ticket Violators
    • Process and Pay fines online
    • Track and Manage all properties, occupants and tenants

    parking permmits
    text message to tenants
    Cloud based parking management
    software for condominiums

    ReplyDelete

  7. It was very useful for me. Keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. This was actually what I was looking for, and I am glad to came here!

    austin web developer
    web design austin

    ReplyDelete
  8. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well..
    Billy lerner

    ReplyDelete
  9. شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بالرياض وجدة والقصيم
    تلجا الكثير من السيدات من فترات الى اخر الى القيام باعمال التجديد للمنزل من خلال تغير قطع من الاثاث حتى يظهر المنزل بابهى صورة لة واحسن ما ترى ، ولكن يكن هناك مشكلة تظهر فى المكان وهى التعرض الى قطع العفش المستعملة التى اصبح لا فائدة لة ، فشركة المستقبل افضل الشركات التى تعمل على
    شراء اثاث مستعمل
    بقطع اخرى جديدة كما تريد ان تختارة فى مقابل اسعار مميزة ترضى عملائنا الكرام . تعمل شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بالرياض على شراء كل انواع الاثاث المتواجد فى المكان من غرف النوم – السفرة – النيش – الكراسى – الدواليب ...من القطع الاثاث وبالاضافة الى المفروشات ايضا من الممكن ان يتم استبدالة من السجاد والمجالس والستائر و... والاجهزة الكهربائية من الشفاطات والتليفزيونات والغسالات ...فى مقابل افضل القطع التى يطلبة بانسب الاسعار وبالاضافة الى اننا نتحمل الانتقال من خلال السيارات الخاصة بالشركة الى المكان المراد الانتقال الية ، فكل ما عليك هو الاتصال بنا لشراء الاثاث وكل ما تستغنى عنة واسعارنا ستكون فى مرضية للطرفين . لا تقتصر شركة المستقبل على القيام باعمال الشراء فقط بل تهتم الشركة بخدمات البيع فنحن متخصصين فى جميع انواع الاثاث المستعمل فى مقابل افضل الاسعار الممكنة ، تقوم الشركة بشراء اى قطعة من الاثاث الكثيرة والمتعددة والمختلفة فى الحجم مهما
    شراء اثاث مستعمل بالرياض
    كانت حالتة فيتم تقييم الاسعار فى مقابل جودتة ونوع المادة المصنوع منها الاثاث وقدرتة على التحمل ومن الممكن ان تصلح للاستخدام مرة اخرى ام لا ، فكلما ارتفعت قيمة قطعة الاثاث كلما ارتفعت الاسعار ، نحن نقدم الخدمات الحصرية التى توفر كل ما تريدة مخصصة للاثاث المستعمل نتعامل بمصداقية وبمنتهى الشفافية فاسعار الشركة لا نتغالى ولا يوجد مثيل لة فى الاسواق عن الاسعار السائدة المتواجدة الان .
    محلات شراء الاثاث المستعمل
    لماذا شركة المستقبل فى شراء الاثاث المستعمل بالرياض ؟ لسنا الوحيدون المتواجدون فى الاسواق ، لكن شركة المستقبل تهتم بمجال البيع والشراء مع تقديم افضل الاسعار وارخصها والعمل على استيراد التحف والاثاث الراقى الذى يتناسب مع جميع الاذواق والتى تتناسب مع ديكورات الفلل والمنازل والشركات والفنادق .
    شراء اثاث مستعمل جدة
    تهتم الشركة بالاسعار الحقيقية التى تقدمة لكم دون ان يتم خصم اسعار المصاريف للشحن والنقل و مصاريف التغليف والعمالة المراد القيام بهذه المهمة ، فشركة المستقبل على اتم استعدلد للقيام باعمال الشراء لاى قطعة من الاثاث والوصول الى اى مكان فى الرياض وخارج الرياض من اجل ان يتم التخلص من الفوضى من شان الاثاث المستعمل . لا تكتفى شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بجدة باعمال الشراء فقط بل تقوم باعمال البيع للاثاث نظرا لان هناك مقارنة كبيرة فى الاسعار وتهتم بتقديم خدمات مميزة فى اعمال البيع لا تستطيع ان يتم تفريقة عن القطع الجديدة .

    ReplyDelete

  10. شركة نقل اثاث
    الاثاث من الاشياء التى نستطيع ان نبذل فية الكثير من الجهد والوقت من اجل ان يتم القيام باعمال النقل من مكان الى اخر سواء الى اى مكان فى المملكة او اى مكان خارج المملكة ، فاعمال النقل من الخدمات التى تبدو لنا انها سهلة وبسيطة الاانة فى نهاية الامر من الخدمات التى تؤدى الى التعرض الى مشاكل كثيرا من الصعب ان يتم القيام بحلها من الكسر والخدش والتلفيات والضياع ،شركة قمم التميز من اهم وافضل الشركات التى تحقق اعلى مستوى من خدمات شراء اثاث مستعمل جدة النقل للاثاث والقيام بالاتفاق مع مركز التعاون الخليجى من اجل ان يتم الحفاظ على الاثاث ضد اى مشكلة ، فاذا كنت فى حيرة من امر النقل فتاكد انك الان تمتلك افضل الشركات
    ارقام شراء الاثاث المستعمل بجدة
    المميزة الخاصة باعمال النقل من خلال الاعتماد على توفير عدد من الخدمات المميزة .
    شراء الاثاث المستعمل بجدة
    شركة قمم التميز على وعى كبير باعمال النقل والتى تحقق افضل مستوى من خدمات النقل التى تؤكد ان الاثاث يتم الانتقال من مكان الى اخر دون ان يتم التعرض الى اى مشكلة من اهم الخدمات المقدمة الاتى :- ارقام محلات شراء الاثاث المستعمل بجدة
    1- الاعتماد على افضل النجاريين المتخصصين فى اعمال الفك بطريقة حرفية لان الاثاث يحتاج الى القيام باعمال الفك الى قطع اصغر من الممكن حتى يتم حماية الاثاث من التعرض الى اى تلفيات او ظهور اى عيب فى الاثاث بعد التركيب .
    2- تعتمد شركة نقل اثاث على افضل الطرق فى التعبئة والتغليف وتوفر النيلون والحبال والبلاستيك ذات الفقاقيع فى اعمال التغليف للزجاج والتغليف للاثاث والتغليف للمراتب وغيرها من الاشياء المتواجدة فى المكان .
    3- التعبئة تتم من خلال صناديق مخصصة مغلقة حتى يتم انتقال بيه الى المكان المراد النقل الية .
    4- اعمال النقل تتم من خلال الاعتماد على شاحنات متخصصة فى اعمال النقل والتى يتم تحميل الاثاث على السيارات من خلال اساليب وطرق النقل الحديثة المميزة .
    5- شراء اثاث مستعمل بجدة
    الاهتمام باعمال النقل بكافة الوسائل المختلفة بالاضافة الى ان الشركة تهتم باعمال النقل من خلال توفير عدد من الوكلاء الخارجين لتسهيل اعمال النقل الان .
    لا تكتفى شركة نقل اثاث بالقيام باعمال النقل فقط بل تهتم باعمال التركيب واعادة الاثاث الى ما كان علية بعد ان تتم اعمال النقل مباشرا
    محلات شراء الاثاث المستعمل بجدة

    ReplyDelete
  11. city park has been kind of thingscity park

    ReplyDelete
  12. Nice post! Are Automatic Parking Barrier good for city parking? Would you recommend so?

    ReplyDelete

  13. Parking software condominium
    email blast to tenants
    Guest parking
    Why apartment owners, condominium owners and management companies use webparkingsoftware.com
    One of the most daunting operational aspects of managing a facility like condominium s and apartment owner is parking system. Finally, this challenge now can be streamlined with the help of smart parking solutions. One of the best providers of these parking management systems is webparkingsoftware.com. What are the reasons why apartment owners, condominium owners and management companies use webparkingsoftware.com? Read on.
    Webparkingsoftware.com is recognized as a reliable service provider of parking problem solutions. They continuously gained the trust of many facility owners and manager and this is because they completely adhere to the most scalable approaches in designing their services. Plus, they also have a highly qualified management team equipped with a lifetime experience when it comes to parking management, IT software and business management.
    Another reason why webparkingsoftware.com is preferred by many facility owners is that they are design excellent parking management software after conducting intensive collaboration of their reputable engineers. In connection to that, they also perform daily procedures on phone, paper,email and fax while applying the sheer power of Cloud technology in improving the delivery system of their organization.
    Regardless the size of facility, http://webparkingsoftware.com has the capability to meet your particular needs. They have already mastered the art of designing state of the art software that will enhance the parking management aspect of your facility. Since they have been in the industry for many years, apartment owners, condominium owners and business owners already have the peace of mind that they are adept in the various needs of their clients in terms of parking management requirement.
    Additionally, webparkingsoftware.com is chosen by many clients because of wide options of excellent features that they have to offer. This includes full parking management system, issuance of professional parking solutions, allocation of guest parking space for tenant, processing of tickets online and many more.
    Plus, many users make the right choice to count on the services of webparkingsoftware.com because they adhere to the latest technology. They want to make sure that they are always one step ahead over their competitors when it comes to parking management. They implement All Internet web-based cloud systems in creating all their products. With them, you can also make sure that there are no hectic paper systems as they are more on automated systems.
    They also offer iPhone functionality in order to come up with an easy use of parking enforcement along with security guards as well as authorized personnel. Since they provide easy add-all registrants features, you are now able to securely online as well as upload consent forms that are necessary for the user.
    The reasons why apartment owners, condominium owners and management companies use webparkingsoftware.com have been explained. If you are adept to the situation, it is a good thing that you also make the right decision. If you are looking for the most scalable, flexible and reliable online parking management software, you can always give your trust to wenparkingsoftare.com as they will assure to have all your needs covered.






    ReplyDelete